First stop: Kiama! As I creep down to sit on the edge of the rocky cliffs, I feel at peace with the world. The turquoise blue water crashes up against the rocks, as the light wind sweeps thin wisps of hair from my face. Behind me, I can hear the sound of the blowhole as it spews into the salty air. Here I am, sitting on the ocean’s edge, on the other side of the world.
We turn around the bend and that’s when I see it. After driving through scenery consisting of nothing but trees for about 20 minutes, there is finally a building along the road up ahead. “East Lynne Store” reads the sign out front.
The bus pulls over in front of the service station and we climb out, anxious to see if this store will live up to the reputation our trip supervisor has given it. I am the first to walk in.
It is quiet, but the air is filled with rich aromas. I try to peel my eyes away from the display of pies and rolls to my left as I approach the counter to talk to the friendly-looking woman standing behind it…
Sharon’s eyes light up and a humble smile appears on her face as she asks me how I found out about her store and why I wanted to write about the little pie shop. “Because I’ve heard it’s amazing,” I respond simply.
Now owned by Sharon Wilkins and her husband, Dean, the store’s first origins are kind of a mystery.
It is thought to have began in the 1930s, but there are myths that it used to be somewhere up the road before relocating to its current address. It also burnt down in 1950, before being revived and becoming the shop it now is, known for its variety of house made pies and other treats.
Thank goodness, for our tastebuds’ sake, it was revitalized.
Originally, the store only served one type of pie: apple. The pies were made from scratch, using apples grown on the land behind the building.
Although there is no longer an apple orchard, the tradition of house made pies has continued and expanded. The store uses fresh ingredients to make all of their menu items on premises. Apple pie is their signature pie, but “all the kinds are getting so popular. We now have custard tart and vanilla slice, as well as items such as lemon meringue and carrot cake,” says Sharon.
Sharon and I chat for a while, as she tells me about her husband, who enjoys riding around on his motorcycle, and how the East Lynne Store has even became involved in his hobby.
They call it “The Pie Ride.” Traditionally, almost every weekend groups of bikers meet in Milton and travel around the state, stopping at the East Lynne Store for a mouth-watering lunch.
Even people from farther away like to indulge in the store’s treats. “People come from Sydney and Wollongong and all over the state to enjoy our pies,” says Sharon. In fact, they sell frozen pies that may also be ordered in bulk if called in ahead of time.
“It’s nice to sell a popular product that everyone loves and enjoys,” says Sharon, as she looks up at me and smiles.
20 minutes later and only $5 poorer, I had purchased my first pie ( I decided to go with apple) and carried it onto the bus as I waved goodbye to Sharon. As soon as I sat down in the uncomfortable blue patterned seats, I took the pie out of the brown paper bag.
I couldn’t stop smelling it. I just kept holding the pie below my nose and breathing in the sweet, doughy scent while its heat warmed my hands. When I finally took the first bite, it tasted just as good as it smelled, like fresh apples wrapped up in a shortbread cookie, topped with crystals of sugar.
I now know why apple is their most popular type of pie. I ate it all.